Tilly

Chalk Eater — Tier 2

Correctly cover the spread while picking the favorite (a negative spread). Pick'em games don't count either way. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 favorite covers. Regular season only.

Underdog — Tier 1

Correctly cover the spread while picking the underdog (a positive spread). Pick'em games don't count either way. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 underdog covers. Regular season only.

Reef Shark — Tier 1

Correctly cover the spread while picking the HOME team. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 home covers. Regular season only.

Murky Waters — Tier 2

Correctly cover the spread while picking the AWAY team. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 road covers. Regular season only.

Arizona Cardinals — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Arizona Cardinals. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Atlanta Falcons — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Atlanta Falcons. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Baltimore Ravens — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Baltimore Ravens. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Buffalo Bills — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Buffalo Bills. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Carolina Panthers — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Carolina Panthers. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Chicago Bears — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Chicago Bears. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Cincinnati Bengals — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Cincinnati Bengals. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Cleveland Browns — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Cleveland Browns. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Dallas Cowboys — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Dallas Cowboys. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Denver Broncos — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Denver Broncos. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Detroit Lions — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Detroit Lions. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Green Bay Packers — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Green Bay Packers. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Houston Texans — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Houston Texans. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Indianapolis Colts — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Indianapolis Colts. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Jacksonville Jaguars — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Jacksonville Jaguars. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Kansas City Chiefs — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Kansas City Chiefs. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Los Angeles Chargers — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Los Angeles Chargers. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Los Angeles Rams — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Los Angeles Rams. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Las Vegas Raiders — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Las Vegas Raiders. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Miami Dolphins — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Miami Dolphins. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Minnesota Vikings — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Minnesota Vikings. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

New England Patriots — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the New England Patriots. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

New Orleans Saints — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the New Orleans Saints. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

New York Giants — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the New York Giants. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

New York Jets — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the New York Jets. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Philadelphia Eagles — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Philadelphia Eagles. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Pittsburgh Steelers — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Pittsburgh Steelers. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Seattle Seahawks — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Seattle Seahawks. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

San Francisco 49ers — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the San Francisco 49ers. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Tennessee Titans — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Tennessee Titans. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Washington Commanders — Locked

Correctly cover the spread with the Washington Commanders. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 correct covers. Regular season only.

Perfect Week — Locked

Correctly pick every game in a week. Regular season only.

Imperfect Week — Locked

Get every game wrong in a week. Regular season only.

Full Slate

Submit a pick for every game in a week, right or wrong. Regular season only.

Lone Shark — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on a pick that 10% or fewer of Baby Sharks users also made for that game. Regular season only.

David

Correctly cover the spread while picking an underdog of +7 points or more. Regular season only.

Barnacle — Locked

Pick the same NFL team in 10 consecutive games it plays — bye weeks don't break the streak, but picking its opponent or skipping the matchup does. Regular season only.

Against the Current — Locked

Correctly cover on 3 or more picks in the same week that 25% or fewer of Baby Sharks users also made. Regular season only.

Sunday Sweep — Locked

Correctly pick every Sunday game in a single week. Regular season only.

Xmas — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on a game played on Christmas Day (December 25). Not every season has one. Regular season only.

Spooky Season — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on a game played on Halloween (October 31). Not every season has one. Regular season only.

Turkey Time — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on a Thanksgiving game (the 4th Thursday of November). Regular season only.

Futbol — Locked

Pick either side of a game that ends in a tie — the rarest result in football. Which team you picked doesn't matter, just that the final score did. Regular season only.

Bird Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 5 bird teams (Cardinals, Falcons, Ravens, Eagles, Seahawks) in the same week. Regular season only.

Cat Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 cat teams (Bengals, Lions, Panthers, Jaguars) in the same week. Regular season only.

AFC East Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 AFC East teams (Bills, Dolphins, Patriots, Jets) in the same week. Regular season only.

AFC North Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 AFC North teams (Ravens, Bengals, Browns, Steelers) in the same week. Regular season only.

AFC South Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 AFC South teams (Texans, Colts, Jaguars, Titans) in the same week. Regular season only.

AFC West Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 AFC West teams (Broncos, Chiefs, Raiders, Chargers) in the same week. Regular season only.

NFC East Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 NFC East teams (Cowboys, Giants, Eagles, Commanders) in the same week. Regular season only.

NFC North Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 NFC North teams (Bears, Lions, Packers, Vikings) in the same week. Regular season only.

NFC South Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 NFC South teams (Falcons, Panthers, Saints, Buccaneers) in the same week. Regular season only.

NFC West Sweep — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on all 4 NFC West teams (Cardinals, Rams, 49ers, Seahawks) in the same week. Regular season only.

Prime Time Prophet — Locked

Correctly pick Thursday/Sunday/Monday night games over your career. Tiers at 10, 25, 50, 75, 100 prime-time wins. Regular season only.

Hot Hand — Tier 1

Correctly call more than half a week's full slate in 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 consecutive weeks. A week at 50% or below breaks the streak — but a tier you've already reached stays earned. Regular season only.

Megalodon — Locked

Finish in the top 1% of the all-time leaderboard once a season is complete — career record, not just that season's. Includes the postseason.

Poseidon — Locked

Finish #1 overall in a completed season’s final standings. Includes the postseason.

Great White — Locked

Finish in the top 5% of eligible players when a season ends. Includes the postseason.

Hammerhead — Locked

Finish in the top 10% of eligible players when a season ends. Includes the postseason.

Tiger Shark — Locked

Finish in the top 25% of eligible players when a season ends. Includes the postseason.

Bottom Feeder — Locked

Finish a completed season with the worst win percentage. Needs picks in at least 8 weeks, and at least 40 picks that won or lost. Includes the postseason.

Ring Caller — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on the Super Bowl. Postseason only.

Conference Call — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on both Conference Championship games in the same postseason. Postseason only.

Divisional Dominance — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on every Divisional Round game in the same postseason. Postseason only.

Wild Card Whisperer — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on every Wild Card Weekend game in the same postseason. Postseason only.

The Perfect Storm — Locked

Correctly cover the spread on every single postseason game — Wild Card through the Super Bowl — in the same year. Postseason only.

Shipwrecked — Locked

Miss the spread on every single postseason game — Wild Card through the Super Bowl — in the same year. Postseason only.

Iron Shark — Locked

Submit a pick for every available game in every week of an entire season — missing even one at any point means the season doesn’t count. Regular season only.

Full House — Locked

Reach at least Team badge Tier 1 (3 correct covers) with all 32 NFL teams. Regular season only.

Deep Sea Collector — Locked

Reach at least Team badge Tier 3 (25 correct covers) with all 32 NFL teams. Regular season only.

Master of the Seas — Locked

Reach Team badge Tier 5 (100 correct covers) with all 32 NFL teams — the ultimate collection achievement. Regular season only.

Deckhand — Locked

Submit 100 career picks — right or wrong, correctness doesn't matter. Regular season only.

First Mate — Locked

Submit 250 career picks — right or wrong, correctness doesn't matter. Regular season only.

Captain — Locked

Submit 500 career picks — right or wrong, correctness doesn't matter. Regular season only.

Admiral — Locked

Submit 1,000 career picks — right or wrong, correctness doesn't matter. Regular season only.

Populus — Tier 1

Reach 10, 100, 1000, 5000, 10000 followers. Tracks your CURRENT follower count, not a lifetime peak — it can go back down a tier if followers leave.

Castaway Courier — Tier 1

Get 1, 10, 25, 50, 100 people to lock in your shark's search code as their referral when they join.

Heartbreaker — Locked

Lose a pick against the spread by 1 point or less — as close as a loss can get without pushing. Tiers at 3, 10, 25, 50, 100 heartbreakers. Regular season only.

The Kraken — Locked

Earn every other badge in Baby Sharks — every team, every milestone, every season award, every Shiver badge, all of it. The ultimate completionist badge.

Jawsvivor Champ — Locked

Win an eligible Jawsvivor pool (at least 10 different accounts competing) — most points when the pool's season ends, ties all count. Tiers at 1, 5, 10, 15, 25 wins.

Sole Survivor — Locked

Win an eligible Classic Survivor pool (at least 10 different accounts competing) — last shark standing (or tied for longest survival) when the pool's season ends. Tiers at 1, 5, 10, 15, 25 wins.

GM of the Year — Locked

Win an eligible Team Fantasy draft (all 8 participants from different accounts) — most deploy wins when the pool's season ends, ties all count. Tiers at 1, 5, 10, 15, 25 wins.

AFC East Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the AFC East winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

AFC North Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the AFC North winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

AFC South Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the AFC South winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

AFC West Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the AFC West winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

NFC East Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the NFC East winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

NFC North Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the NFC North winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

NFC South Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the NFC South winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

NFC West Oracle — Locked

Correctly call the NFC West winner in a Futures Pick 'Em pool.

Triple Crown — Locked

Correctly call BOTH conference champs and the Super Bowl winner in the same Futures Pick 'Em pool.

Beta Season Survivor

Sign up for BabySharks before or during the 2026 season.

Co-Flounder — Locked

Awarded to a handful of early supporters who helped shape BabySharks from the start.